But saying "I’m sorry" and doing nice things and making promises is not actively doing anything towards making permanent changes and is merely showing that they are sorry.
There is a difference between regret (getting caught) and remorse (true regret and wanting to make amends).
I agree with all of this.
It sounds like he has a lot of regret. He's willing to do you favors, make romantic gestures, and apologize. That's him focused on winning you back - getting what he wants.
Has he said there's something wrong with him? Is he working to figure out what that is and fix it (with no prompting from you)? Has he said he needs to change, and is he working on himself to change? Is he holding himself back from you until he feels like he's a changed man (good), or is he asking you to take him back and give him another chance (not good)?
I think my confusion about what to do lies in that I genuinely never had a connection like this with anyone before ever and for the first time I actually saw a future with someone.
What's worse, being with a man who is self-centered (puts his own desires first), or being on your own?
Right now, just 18 months in, he has shown you who he is. Let him work on himself and come back to you a year from now. If he can change without you in the picture, then he wants to be a different person for himself. That's when true change occurs. If you're in the picture, it's about him getting you back, and that kind of change won't last in my experience.
Tell him you'll wait for a year, if you want, but go no contact and stay that way for the entire year. Then meet with him like it's a new first date - get to know what he's been doing, what kind of person he is. You'll both be a little different after a year apart. If you like the new him, then try again. If he seems like the same old guy, or if he's moved on to someone else, then he was never right for you.
DDay1 Nov 2022: WX admitted to a 3yr LTA with AP1.
DDay4 Sep 2023: WX confessed an EA from 2014 with AP2.
Married 25 years on DDay1.
Tried R for 2.5 years. Divorced Aug 2026.